Scar
The Lion King · 1994
Fratricide, a musical number, and a lifetime of resentment
The villain whose weapon is a compliment with a knife in it
Editorial estimates on a 0–100 scale, calibrated against every other character in the index. Not official canon.
Gothel kidnaps a child to use her hair as an anti-aging treatment and then raises her with a steady drip of affectionate insults, jokes framed as concern, and the constant implication that the outside world will destroy her. She never casts a spell at the heroine. She does not need to. She is the most accurate depiction of emotional manipulation in the studio's catalogue.
She has spent eighteen years making sure her victim believes leaving would kill her.
Her power is entirely borrowed. Cut the hair and she has nothing at all.
She never casts a spell at her victim. She uses affection, jokes and concern, and it is the most accurate depiction of manipulation the studio has produced.
The Lion King · 1994
Fratricide, a musical number, and a lifetime of resentment
The Hunchback of Notre Dame · 1996
The darkest antagonist a major animation studio has ever released
Avatar: The Last Airbender · 2005
Kept in shadow for two full seasons, and worth the wait